Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
The low-echo centroid (LEC) storm, characterized by the dominance of warm-rain processes and high precipitation efficiency (Vitale Ryan, 2013), is generally associated with high-intensity rainfall events in tropical and subtropical regions (Hamada et al. 2015). While many double-moment microphysical parameterization schemes are primarily designed for deep convection or cold-rain processes, research on their performance in simulating LEC warm-cloud precipitation systems is limited. In this study, we investigate an extreme rainfall case that occurred on 20 July 2016 in northern China, resulting in over 600 mm of maximum 24-hour accumulated rainfall. According to radar observations, the case is characterized by LEC structure. Using the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model with 4 km grid spacing, we simulate this event employing the Morrison, Thompson, and Milbrandt-Yau double-moment microphysics schemes. Evaluation based on simulated infrared brightness temperature (BT) using a radiative transfer model and simulated reflectivity reveals that while different microphysics schemes generally predict rainfall amount, location, and propagation accurately, they fail to replicate the three-dimensional cloud structures. The simulated convective cores (>35dBZ) are higher than -10 C, indicating active cold-cloud processes, while the observed LEC suggests the dominance of warm-cloud processes. The model produces an excessive number of upper-level clouds and overshooting clouds, also overpredict the cloud-top height. Sensitivity experiments show that simulated brightness temperatures are primarily influenced by the concentration of cloud ice particles. Morrison and Milbrandt-Yau microphysics schemes produces an overabundance of cloud ice particles in the upper layer, leading to the overproduction of uppe-level cloud and incorrect representation of cloud top height. Warm-rain processes are not fully developed, and the cold-rain processes are not effectively restrained, resulting in unrealistic cloud structure. By adjusting microphysical processes in the schemes, such as increasing cloud water number concentration, the simulated convective cores align more closely with the observed ones. In summary, while the current microphysics schemes effectively simulate rainfall intensity and propagation, there is a clear need for improvement in simulating the cloud particle distribution and vertical structure of LEC storms. Our findings underscore the importance of refining microphysical parameterization schemes for accurate simulation of extreme rainfall events.
Yang et al. (Sat,) studied this question.