Analysis of the Effectiveness of Water Hammer Protection Programs for Complex Long-Distance and High-Head Water Supply Projects

The purpose of this research is to solve the complex long-distance and high-lift water supply engineering accident water hammer protection problem. Taking the Zhaojinzhuang water supply project as an example, based on the method of characteristics (MOC), the water hammer of the pumping station under the combined action of a water hammer relief valve, hydraulic-control butterfly valve, air vessel, air valve, and other water hammer protection measures is numerically simulated and calculated, and the effectiveness of the range method is analyzed, to ensure a waterproof hammer in pump stop accidents. The results show that the main factors affecting the effect of water hammer protection under the two-stage valve-closing parameters of the hydraulic-control butterfly valve are the fast-closing angle and the slow-closing time. The arrangement of the air vessel behind the pump can effectively increase the minimum water hammer pressure in the climbing section, and with the increase of the volume of the air vessel, the pump reverse speed and the maximum positive pressure increase slightly, but the overall water hammer protection effect is better. With the increase of the moment of inertia of the motor, the maximum positive pressure and minimum negative pressure of the pipeline still do not meet the requirements of the specification, and the modification cost is relatively large. The combination of the one-stage hydraulic-control butterfly valve, the air valve, the air vessel, and the water hammer relief valve can effectively reduce the volume of the air vessel. Under the optimal method, the maximum positive pressure head is 236.61 m, and the minimum negative pressure head is −3.18 m. Compared with the original method, the maximum positive pressure head is increased by 1.18%, the minimum negative pressure head is reduced by 95.78%, the maximum reverse speed of the pump is reduced by 100%, and the maximum reverse flow of the pump is reduced by 70.27%, meeting the requirements of water hammer protection. This is a safe and economical protection method.