Comprehensive Comparison of Physical and Behavioral Approaches for Virtual Prototyping and Accurate Modeling of Three-Phase EMI Filters

This paper addresses and compares the modeling of typical EMI filters used in three-phase power equipment obtained through two different approaches, namely, physical and behavioral. Firstly, an innovative physical EMI filter modeling procedure is presented, which relies on an analytical formulation in terms of chain-parameters matrices and allows for an easy evaluation of its attenuation characteristics. The considered procedure builds an overall filter model by combining simple components models, requiring the determination of only a limited number of parasitic elements. Furthermore, the latter can be easily estimated without the need to build any prototype, avoiding the costly trial-and-error design procedures currently applied in the industrial context. Additionally, the considered physical model is tailored for high-power filters, built with thick wires, while most of the physical models available in the literature are aimed at small-sized filters built on printed circuit boards. The procedure is validated step by step, discussing the accuracy of each component model and its impact on overall accuracy compared to the actual measurements of the final assembled filter. Secondly, a behavioral modeling procedure is presented, which is based on external measurements performed on the filter prototype and provides an equivalent circuit model. Specifically, it extends to three-phase filters a circuit model previously developed for the single-phase case. Lastly, a critical comparison between the proposed physical and behavioral models is presented, highlighting the strengths and limitations of both and suggesting optimal uses for each.