The Risks of Risk Assessment: Causal Blind Spots When Using Prediction Models for Treatment Decisions

An extension of guidelines for the development, reporting, and evaluation of prediction models is advocated to avoid such misinterpretations. Developers must ensure that the intended target population for the model, and the treatment conditions under which predictions hold, are clearly communicated. When prediction models are intended to inform treatment decisions, they need to provide estimates of risk under the specific treatment (or intervention) options being considered, known as "prediction under interventions." Next to suitable data, this requires causal reasoning and causal inference techniques during model development and evaluation. Being clear about what a given prediction model can and cannot be used for prevents misinformed treatment decisions and thereby prevents potential harm to patients.