Abstract Water was a prominent substance with Pythagoras, Xenophanes, Heraclitus and Parmenides, who flou rished in the years 530-490 bc. The basic Pythagore an elements were earth and fire, and between them there were 2 intermediate entities (water and air), which were instrumental and indispensable com ponents of specific solids. All things are a blend of different elements. For Xenophanes, “All things that come into being and grow are earth and water,” “We all originated from earth and water” and “And in certain caves water drips down.”For Heraclitus water is an ambivalent substance: “One cannot ba the in the same river on two occasions.” “The sea is the safest and the most polluted water, for fish it is healthy and gives life, for men it is unhealthy and causes death.” “Fire experiences the death of earth, air experiences that of fire, water experiences the death of air and the earth that of water.” Parmeni des was a man who sought the truth through re asoning and was, according to Hegel, the founder of Western philosophy. He built a dualist theory of the cosmos based on heat and cold, fire and earth - the former as a cause, the latter as substrate. The former unified, the latter separated. According to Aristotle, Parmenides considered air and water as mixtures of earth and fire.
Bisaccia et al. (Thu,) studied this question.