China has implemented extensive land restoration programs and now leads the world in artificial forest area. However, such plantations often face degradation, largely due to soil nutrient deficiency. In contrast, near-natural restoration tends to result in better soil quality, ecosystem integrity, and stability. This study focuses on three near-naturally restored sites on the Loess Plateau—a critical part of China’s National Ecological Security Barrier System, which has undergone substantial ecological restoration in recent decades. Using soil stoichiometry to assess nutrient balance and land sustainability, we investigated two forest types (Betula platyphylla, BP; Larix principis-rupprechtii, LP) and a mixed shrubland (Ostryopsis davidiana and Cotoneaster multiflorus, OD–CM). Soil profiles were sampled at 20 cm intervals from the surface to bedrock. We measured soil carbon (C), nitrogen (N), and phosphorus (P) contents, along with key environmental factors. The results show the following: (1) The two forest lands exhibited similar C and N levels, which were 1.23–1.26 and 1.40–1.51 times higher, respectively, than those in the shrubland. (2) Lower C/N (BP: 25.05; LP: 23.46) and higher N/P (BP: 4.83; LP: 5.00) in the forest lands indicated lower nitrogen limitation versus the shrubland (C/N: 28.55; N/P: 3.44). (3) Key influencing factors varied across land restoration types, indicating that the vegetation community’s composition mediates nutrient cycling through nutrient uptake and litter input. (4) Relative to plantations in the same region, near-naturally restored lands had 3.47–5.64 times higher C content and 1.51–2.51 times higher N content. Moreover, near-natural communities exhibited higher C/N (21.68–30.56) and C/P (85.92–132.97) compared to plantations (C/N: 8.8–13.1; C/P: 9.16–31.2), reflecting more efficient nitrogen and phosphorus utilization. Thus, near-natural land restoration enhances soil carbon sequestration, nitrogen fixation, and nutrient use efficiency on the Loess Plateau, supporting its promotion as a superior land management strategy for enhancing land sustainability and ecosystem services in this area.
Guo et al. (Thu,) studied this question.