Women harboring pathogenic variant (PV) in the BRCA1 or BRCA2 genes (= BRCA) have an elevated lifetime risk for breast cancer (BC). One of the main options for active BC risk reduction is bilateral risk-reducing mastectomy (RRM). Understanding the factors influencing that decision is important for genetic-counselling and risk mitigation strategy planning. A structured questionnaire was circulated to BRCA carriers, members of the Good Genes NGO in Israel. Data on RRM uptake and timing, factors previously reported to be associated with decision to undergo RRM (e.g., psychosocial, family history, counselling/health-system factors) were obtained. Comparison between carriers who elected to undergo RRM with those who opted for early detection schemes were performed using logistic regression and chi square statistical analyses. Of cancer free women (n = 391), 272 (69.6%) elected to adhere to the recommended surveillance scheme and 119 (30.4%) elected to undergo RRM. The major reasons for electing RRM over surveillance were active BC risk reduction (4.96 ± 0.23), fear of developing BC (4.86 ± 0.50), and having at least one relative with BC diagnosed under age 45 years. Support group discussions emerged as a stronger determinant of RRM uptake than primary care physician or religious guidance. In conclusion, among healthy Israeli BRCA carriers the decision to undergo RRM was influenced by a complex interplay of factors-active BC risk reduction, fear of cancer diagnosis in the context of having one relative with early onset BC and support group discussions were the major drivers of RRM in Israeli BRCA1 carriers.
Laitman et al. (Wed,) studied this question.