Nine sets of fin parameter combinations, including a plain tube control group, were modeled. Simulations were performed under steady-state conditions using the EWT Realizable k-ε turbulence model, with benzene and water as working fluids, while accounting for temperature-dependent thermophysical properties. Flow field distribution, temperature profile, Nusselt number, and pressure drop in the shell side of the heat exchanger were analyzed. Response surface methodology was employed to systematically evaluate the coupled effects of fin height and fin spacing on thermal performance. The results indicate that annular fins significantly enhance heat transfer by inducing secondary flow and disrupting the thermal boundary layer. Compared to the smooth tube, the finned tubes increased the Nusselt number (Nu) by up to 28.6% and the total heat transfer rate by 13.55%, while the pressure drop (ΔP) increased by approximately 9.81% to 16.5%. The analysis revealed that fin height is the dominant factor affecting performance, whereas fin spacing plays a regulatory role. As the fins became taller or denser, the temperature field evolved from stable stratification to intense mixing and eventually to local disorder. The study identified an optimal parameter range for engineering applications. A fin height of 2–3 mm combined with a spacing of 10–15 mm achieves the best balance between heat transfer enhancement and flow resistance. Specifically, the combination of h = 3 mm and s = 10 mm yielded the highest Energy Efficiency Coefficient (EEC) of 1.567. This configuration is recommended for large-flow, pressure-drop-sensitive systems, such as those found in petrochemical plants or long-distance heat transmission applications.
Lan et al. (Mon,) studied this question.