Review of: The CHIPS Database: A Repository for Reference Data on Chemical Analysis in Archaeometallurgy of Iron. Round#1/Reviewer#3

Key Points

• This review aims to assess the CHIPS Database as a significant resource for chemical analysis related to archaeometallurgy of iron.
• Evaluated the content and usability of the CHIPS Database.
• Analyzed the relevance of reference data for archaeological studies.
• Recommended improvements for data accessibility and organization.
• The CHIPS Database effectively consolidates chemical analysis data for iron archaeology.
• Identified gaps in data that could be addressed to enhance user experience.
• Highlights the importance of centralized data for researchers in the field.