Urban flood frequency analysis faces unique challenges as land development alters watershed hydrology, producing nonstationary flood records. This study demonstrates nonstationary flood frequency analysis (NSFFA) using RMC-BestFit, an open-source Bayesian software, through two Texas case studies. Brays Bayou at Houston (96 years of record) exemplifies an urbanized watershed with increasing flood trends; a step-logistic model captures both the abrupt increase in mean flood magnitude around 1968 and the progressive decrease in log-space variance as urbanization homogenized runoff response. O.C. Fisher Reservoir (169 years of record) exhibits decreasing trends attributed to brush encroachment and groundwater extraction; despite a sinusoidal model achieving best information criteria, a step function was selected based on physical reasoning, demonstrating that statistical fit alone should not dictate model selection. Results reveal contrasting frequency curve patterns: at O.C. Fisher, stationary and nonstationary curves differ uniformly (53% reduction in 100-year flood), while at Brays Bayou, curves differ substantially for frequent events (48% increase in 2-year flood) but converge in the extreme tail due to opposing trends in location and scale parameters. These findings underscore that NSFFA relevance depends on decision context. Bayesian methods offer key advantages including flexible integration of diverse data sources, comprehensive uncertainty quantification, and principled model comparison. Open-source software democratizes access to these methods, promoting transparency and reproducibility.
Smith et al. (Sat,) studied this question.