Livestock manure resources are abundant in the upper Yellow River basin on the eastern Tibetan Plateau, where rapeseed (Brassica napus L.) is grown under cold, short-season alpine conditions. To identify a suitable organic fertilizer substitution proportion, a two-year randomized complete block field experiment was conducted on Chestnut soil (Kastanozem) to compare mineral fertilization with 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% replacement of mineral N by an organic fertilizer produced from composted cattle and sheep manure under equal total N, P, and K inputs. Grain yield was highest at 50% substitution, increasing by about 14% relative to mineral fertilization (p < 0.05), whereas 100% substitution slightly reduced yield. Increasing manure inputs enlarged soil organic carbon and total nutrient pools, but these increases were not accompanied by proportional increases in plant-available nutrients. Compared with mineral fertilization, 50% substitution increased available N, P, and K by about 18%, 34%, and 10%, respectively, and also increased the proportions of total N, P, and K present in available forms. Activities of the measured extracellular enzymes were generally 12–72% higher under 50% substitution than under mineral fertilization. A piecewise structural equation model indicated that yield improvement was associated mainly with greater nutrient uptake and recovery efficiency. Overall, moderate substitution best balanced nutrient accumulation, nutrient availability, efficiency, and productivity under the tested alpine conditions.
Quan et al. (Thu,) studied this question.