Turbofan engine performance is critically sensitive to operating conditions, yet comprehensive frameworks that simultaneously assess exergo-economic, exergo-environmental, and lifecycle cost performance across realistic flight envelopes remain limited, particularly for Gulf-region climates. In this study, we present a comprehensive analysis of the exergo-economic, exergo-environmental, and lifecycle costings of five different configurations of two-spool and triple-spool turbofan engines. The analysis was carried out for a wide range of four operating conditions, namely ambient temperature, flight altitude, Mach number, and % relative humidity, with emphasis on the climate conditions likely to be found in the Gulf region. The computational models developed were validated against published data to confirm their reliability. It was found that fuel consumption was the most significant contributor to total lifecycle ownership cost, between 60 and 75% of hourly operating cost over a 20-year service period. Ambient temperature, Mach number, and Cruise altitude represented the most significant drivers of long-term economic performance, with % relative humidity having little effect. Exergo-economic analysis showed that the major cost mechanisms changed dramatically with operating conditions. Exergy destruction and component inefficiencies determined the costs at Takeoff, with capital investment being the dominant factor when cruising. Increase in both or either ambient temperature and altitude was shown to reduce cost rates but simultaneously reduced thermo-economic efficiency via higher specific exergy costs. However, increase in Mach number enhances both exergy output and cost-effectiveness, confirming that specific exergy cost is a more reliable indicator of true system performance than cost rate alone. The two-spool configurations show superior specific CO2 emissions, with Case 3 recording the lowest emissions at Takeoff and Case 2 at Cruise. For exergy-based environmental indicators, Case 3 performs best at both Takeoff and Cruise, achieving the lowest environmental destruction coefficient and index, as well as the highest environmental benign index among all five configurations. These findings provide actionable guidance for engine selection, operational optimization, and sustainable propulsion system design.
Almutairi et al. (Mon,) studied this question.