This paper presents a flutter analysis of the UHBR Open Fan Testcase ECL5 for an off-design point at part speed and focuses on the second eigenmode, which has a strong torsional character near the blade tip. Recent studies by Pagès et al., using a time-linearized solver, showed strong negative damping for an operating point at 80% speed close to the maximal pressure ratio. This was identified as a phenomenon of convective resonance; for a certain nodal diameter and frequency, the blade vibration is in resonance with convective disturbances that are linearly unstable. In this work, a nonlinear frequency domain method (harmonic balance) is applied to the problem of aerodynamic damping prediction for this off-design operating point. It is shown that, to obtain plausible results, it is necessary to treat the turbulence model as unsteady. The impact of spurious reflections due to numerical boundary conditions is estimated for this case. While strong negative damping is not predicted by the analysis presented here, we observe particularly high sensitivity of the aerodynamic response with respect to turbulence model formulation and the frequency for certain nodal diameters. The combination of nodal diameter and frequency of maximal sensitivities are interpreted as points near resonance. We recover from these near-resonance points convective speeds and compare them to studies of the onset of nonsynchronous vibrations of the ECL5 fan at part-speed conditions.
Frey et al. (2025) studied this question.