This study evaluates the effectiveness of air pollution control measures in Xi’an, China, by investigating long-term changes in the concentrations, optical properties, and sources of black carbon (BC) and brown carbon (BrC). Wintertime observations of PM2.5 carbonaceous aerosols were conducted over multiple years using a continuous Aethalometer. The data were analyzed using advanced aethalometer models, potential source contribution function (PSCF) analysis, and generalized additive models (GAMs) to deconstruct emission sources and formation pathways. Our results revealed a significant decrease in the mass concentration and light absorption coefficient of BC (babs-BC) between the earlier and later study periods, indicating successful emission reductions. In contrast, the light absorption from BrC (babs-BrC) remained relatively stable, suggesting persistent and distinct emission sources. Source apportionment analysis demonstrated a temporal shift in dominant regional influences, from biomass burning in the initial years to coal combustion in later years. In addition, GAMs showed that the primary driver for liquid fuel-derived BC transitioned from gasoline to diesel vehicle emissions. For solid fuels, residential coal combustion consistently contributed over 50% of BC, highlighting that improvements in coal combustion technology were effective in reducing BC emissions. Furthermore, a substantial fraction of BrC was increased, with nocturnal peaks associated with high relative humidity, emphasizing the aqueous-phase formation influences. Collectively, these findings demonstrated that although certain control strategies successfully mitigated BC, the persistent challenge of BrC pollution necessitates targeted measures addressing secondary formation and primary fossil fuel sources.
Li et al. (2026) studied this question.