Author response of: Adaptive effects of geographic origin on tree ring width and radial growth -climate relationships in Pinus nigra Arnold, the European black pine. Round#1

Key Points

• The study aims to evaluate how geographic origin affects the relationship between tree ring width and radial growth in Pinus nigra.
• Reviewed previous findings on tree ring width and radial growth in Pinus nigra.
• Discussed the implications of geographic origin on climate responses.
• Highlighted variations in growth effects based on different origins.
• Identified adaptive responses related to geographic origins.
• Emphasized the importance of understanding local climate influences.
• Found evidence supporting differences in growth-climate relationships across regions.