PulseExploreJournal ClubDebatesTrendingResearchersJournals
Instagram
HomeExploreJournal ClubTrending
Synapse
⌘+K
Synapse
December 1, 2000The Journal of Philosophy3,240 citations

The Social Construction of What?

View Full Paper
JDJohn DupréIHIan Hacking

Key Points

  • To clarify the precise targets, validity, and boundaries of social constructionism across natural sciences, human classifications, and scientific research.
  • Philosophical and conceptual analysis of social constructionist frameworks across scientific and human domains.
  • Case analysis examining biological versus social models of mental illness, the emergence of child abuse definitions, weapons research dynamics, and anthropological disputes regarding Captain Cook in Hawaii.
  • Distinguishes between the social construction of conceptual classifications and the underlying material or biological realities, clarifying tensions in areas like mental illness.
  • Illustrates that external factors, such as weapons funding, determine the structural direction and form of scientific enterprise rather than its empirical content.
  • Demonstrates how differing cultural frameworks shape interpretation and debate within ethnographic and anthropological scholarship.

Abstract

Often lost in the debate over the validity of social construction is the question of what is being constructed. Particularly troublesome in this area is the status of the natural sciences, where there is conflict between biological and social approaches to mental illness, and in other areas. Ian Hacking looks at the issue of child abuse, and examines the ways in which advanced research on new weapons influences not the content but the form of science. In conclusion, Hacking comments on the culture wars in anthropology, in particular the spat between leading enthnographers over Hawaii and Captain Cook.

Ask AI
Helpful
Bookmark
Share
View Full Paper

Cite This Study

Dupré et al. (2000) studied this question.

synapsesocial.com/papers/6a0ad72e9b4eb2f7ce2e2004https://doi.org/10.2307/2678463
Ask AI
Helpful
Bookmark
Share
View Full Paper