PulseExploreJournal ClubDebatesTrendingResearchersJournals
Instagram
HomeExploreJournal ClubTrending
Synapse
⌘+K
Synapse
July 17, 2021Cuestiones Políticas12 citationsOpen Access

Unconstitutionality of criminal liability for filing inaccurate information in Ukraine: сritical legal analyses

AVAndrii VozniukDKDmitriy KamenskyODOlexandr Dudorov

Key Points

  • Assess the legal justification and constitutional validity of invalidating criminal penalties for non-submission and false reporting of asset declarations.
  • Applied terminological, systemic-structural, formal-logical, and comparative-legal analysis methods.
  • Evaluated constitutional authority limits regarding criminalization alongside foreign legal practices and rule-of-law principles.
  • Demonstrated that determining the criminalization of socially harmful conduct falls under the legislative authority rather than constitutional judicial jurisdiction.
  • Identified that the judicial decision lacked substantiation regarding the absence of social harm in submitting inaccurate asset declarations.

Abstract

The investigation reveals shortcomings in the arguments of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on the recognition of article 366-1 of the Criminal Code as not being in conformity with the Constitution, in terms of:(a) the court's lack of authority to criminalize socially dangerous acts; (b) lack of argumentation on the absence of social harm in the non-submission of a declaration and in the presentation of inaccurate information; (c) positive foreign experience; (d) conformity of article 366-1 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine with the principle of the rule of law. The article employs a set of legal research methods, including terminological, systemic-structural, formal-logical, and comparative-legal. It is stressed that:(a) the criminalization of a socially harmful act is a matter for the legislator, not the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, to decide; (b) the decision does not present or refute any argument on the element of social harmfulness relating to the non-submission of a declaration and the declaration of inaccurate information. On the basis of the investigation, it has been concluded that the decision of the Constitutional Court on the recognition of article 366-1 of the Criminal Code does not comply with the Constitution and has not been sufficiently substantiated.

Ask AI
Helpful
Bookmark
Share
View Full Paper

Cite This Study

Vozniuk et al. (2021) studied this question.

synapsesocial.com/papers/6a0dc591e9dfe5e7c4ba6b6bhttps://doi.org/10.46398/cuestpol.3969.07
Ask AI
Helpful
Bookmark
Share
View Full Paper