The Spite Lithium Plateau: Ultrathin but Postprimordial

We have studied 23 very metal-poor field turnoff stars, specifically chosen to enable a precise measurement of the dispersion in the lithium abundance of the Spite Li plateau. We concentrated on stars having a narrow range of effective temperature and very low metallicities (Fe/H < -2.5) to reduce the effects of systematic errors, and have made particular efforts to minimize random errors in equivalent width and effective temperature. A typical formal error for our abundances is 0.033 dex (1-sigma), which represents a factor of two improvement on most previous studies. Our observed spread about the Li Spite plateau is a mere 0.031 dex (1-sigma), hence we conclude the intrinsic spread is effectively zero at the very metal-poor halo turnoff. We recover a robust dependence of lithium abundance with metallicity, dA(Li)/dFe/H = 0.118 +/- 0.023 dex per dex. Previous claims for a lack of dependence of A(Li) on Fe/H are shown to have arisen from the use of noisier estimates of effective temperatures and metallicities. Although we cannot rule out a uniform depletion mechanism, the lack of spread in the A(Li) abundances limits permissible depletion by current rotationally- induced mixing models to < 0.1 dex. Correcting for the GCE contribution to both 6Li and 7Li, we infer a primordial lithium abundance of A(Li) = 2.0 dex. We predict that observations of lithium in extremely low-metallicity stars, having Fe/H < -3.0, will yield smaller A(Li) values than the bulk of the stars in this sample, consistent with a low primordial abundance.