Higher internal Health Locus of Control predicts positive health behaviors, while higher chance HLOC predicts behaviors leading to adverse outcomes across 50 reviewed studies.
Systematic Review (n=50)
Do Health Locus of Control constructs affect patient responses to medical behavioral interventions?
Higher internal Health Locus of Control is associated with positive health behaviors, whereas higher chance HLOC is linked to adverse health behaviors, suggesting interventions should aim to improve internal HLOC.
BACKGROUND: Health locus of control (HLOC) is a theory that describes how individuals perceive different forces that influence their lives. The concept of a locus of control can affect an individual's likelihood to commit to behaviors related to their health. This study explores the literature on the relationships between HLOC and medical behavioral interventions. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to better understand how HLOC constructs can potentially affect patient responses to health behavioral interventions and to propose a series of guidelines for individuals interested in designing medical behavioral interventions related to HLOC. METHODS: We used the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) methodology and performed an analysis of 50 papers related to the topic of HLOC and medical behavioral interventions. Inclusion criteria were studies that had a behavioral intervention involving patients and contained a metric of at least 1 of the constructs related to HLOC. The initial screening and search were conducted by 2 researchers (AY and SM) separately. The results were then combined and compared. RESULTS: Our findings explore the influence of different levels of HLOC along with the importance of both patient- and health-related context when assessing the relationships between HLOC constructs and the likelihood of health behavior change. The findings show that different constructs related to HLOC can act as reliable predictors for patient responses to medical behavioral interventions. Patients who score higher on internal HLOC measures are more likely to exhibit behaviors that are consistent with positive health outcomes. Patients who score higher on chance HLOC are more likely to exhibit behaviors that may lead to adverse health outcomes. These conclusions are supported by most of the 50 studies surveyed. CONCLUSIONS: We propose guidelines for individuals designing medical behavioral interventions so that they can make use of these relationships linked to HLOC. The three guidelines suggested are as follows: (1) in most situations, improving internal HLOC will improve health outcomes for patients; (2) patients with high external HLOC should be further studied to determine the source of the external HLOC; and (3) patients with a high chance HLOC are less likely to follow preventative behaviors or be responsive to interventions. Limitations of the study are that the primary search and analysis were conducted by 2 principal researchers (AY and SM). Interpretation and development of the guidelines are subject to individual interpretation of results and may not be applicable to all contexts.
Mozafari et al. (2024) conducted a systematic review in Health behavior change (n=50). Health Locus of Control (HLOC) was evaluated on Patient responses to health behavioral interventions. Higher internal Health Locus of Control predicts positive health behaviors, while higher chance HLOC predicts behaviors leading to adverse outcomes across 50 reviewed studies.