The Subjects of Tort Law

Abstract To the extent they consider the matter, tort theorists sometimes assume that the subjects of authority in tort law are the citizens of the state whose tort law applies. This assumption underlies democratic and social contractarian accounts of how to justify the authority of tort law. But as the doctrine of private international law—particularly choice of law—reveals, the subject of tort law is not the citizen, but the generic person; and authority in tort law is not grounded in the state-citizen relationship. Instead, choice of law rules reveal a more complex picture of how tort structures authority. Here, I offer a sketch of an approach that can justify tort law’s authority over persons, not citizens. And I discuss how this analysis may require us to rethink not just the subjects of tort law but also the subject of tort law: the nature of its primary rights and duties.