Cervical cancer remains a major health burden among women in sub-Saharan Africa, where screening is often limited. Persistent high-risk human papillomavirus (HR-HPV) infection is the principal cause, highlighting the need for accurate molecular diagnostics. This cross-sectional study evaluated the analytical performance of one mRNA assay, APTIMA® HPV assay (APTIMA mRNA), and two DNA-based assays, the Abbott RealTime High Risk HPV assay (Abbott DNA) and Seegene Allplex™ II HPV28 assay (Seegene DNA), in 527 cervical samples from a South African tertiary hospital, focusing on 14 shared HR-HPV genotypes. Seegene DNA yielded the highest detection rate (53.7%), followed by Abbott DNA (48.2%) and APTIMA mRNA (45.2%). APTIMA mRNA showed a strong agreement with Abbott DNA (87.9%, κ = 0.80), 89.9% sensitivity, 91.2% NPV, and the highest accuracy (AUC = 0.8804 vs. 0.8681). The agreement between APTIMA mRNA and Seegene DNA was moderate (83.4%, κ = 0.70), reflecting target differences. Many DNA-positive/mRNA-negative cases likely represent transient infections, though some may be latent with reactivation potential, warranting a follow-up. In resource-constrained settings, prioritizing transcriptionally active infections through mRNA testing may enhance screening efficiency and reduce burden. Scalable, cost-effective assays with strong clinical utility are essential for broadening access and improving cervical cancer prevention. Further studies should assess the integration of mRNA testing into longitudinal screening algorithms.
Nkwinika et al. (Fri,) studied this question.