Importance Urinary tract infection (UTI) is common in ambulatory care settings and the primary reason for antibiotic prescribing. Despite several guidelines focused on the type and duration of antibiotics prescribed for treating UTI, there is limited outpatient guidance on how to best triage patients with presumed UTI. Objective To assess the appropriateness of different triage and management recommendations involving empiric antibiotics, urine testing strategies, and visit types and how these recommendations vary by patient sex, age, presenting symptoms, and clinical history. Evidence Review Using the RAND/UCLA Appropriateness Method, a 13-member multidisciplinary panel (physicians, advanced practice providers, and nurses) performed a scoping review of the literature publications from 2009 to June 2024 and rated the appropriateness of 136 clinical scenarios (48 for women, 49 for men, and 39 scenarios not specific to sex) with up to 9 management strategies per scenario for a total of 1094 scenarios. For each scenario, experts rated the appropriateness of empiric treatment, types of urine testing, and triage to visit type (in-person, virtual, or none) as appropriate (ie, benefits outweigh risks), inappropriate, or of uncertain appropriateness. Appropriateness ratings were summarized into 2 groups: nonpregnant adult women and adult men. Findings Major recommendations based on symptoms included (1) same-day in-person evaluation if symptoms were concerning for pyelonephritis, complicated cystitis, or urinary obstruction; (2) a visit if additional nonurinary symptoms were present (ie, diarrhea, genital discharge, or cough); (3) neither urine testing nor empiric treatment solely due to a change in urine color or appearance without other bladder (cystitis) symptoms; (4) empiric treatment without testing or a visit, for women, if there were new classic cystitis symptoms of dysuria, urinary frequency, urgency, or suprapubic pain without risks for antibiotic resistance; (5) urinalysis with culture (ideally reflexed to culture) before taking first antibiotic dose for women at risk of antibiotic resistance (eg, recent antibiotic treatment for UTI or recurrent UTIs) and all men; and (6) empiric treatment considered for patients with barriers to obtaining timely urine testing or visits. Conclusions and Relevance The appropriateness of empiric antibiotics, urine testing, and different clinical evaluation options were defined for adults presenting with concerns for UTI in common ambulatory triage settings, including telehealth. These criteria for ambulatory triage of suspected UTI symptoms in adults are anticipated to help standardize and improve the appropriateness of empiric antibiotic prescribing, urine testing, and visit type triage.
Meddings et al. (Thu,) studied this question.