In the Jimusaer Sag of the Junggar Basin, crude oils from the upper and lower sweet-spot intervals of the Permian Lucaogou Formation display a pronounced “light-heavy reversal” in oil properties that indicates a fundamental mismatch between oil composition and host rock maturity. To resolve this anomaly, this study integrates geological, geochemical, and petrophysical datasets and systematically evaluates the combined roles of thermal evolution, organofacies, wettability, abnormal overpressure, and migration-related fractionation on shale oil composition. On this basis, a “staged charging-cumulative charging” model is proposed to explain compositional heterogeneity in lacustrine shale oils. The results demonstrate that crude-oil compositions are jointly controlled by the extent of biomarker depletion, the temporal evolution of hydrocarbon charging, and the openness of the source-reservoir system, rather than by thermal maturity or organofacies alone. The upper sweet-spot interval is interpreted to have functioned as a semi-open system during early stages, in which hydrocarbon generation and expulsion were broadly synchronous, leading to preferential loss of early-generated, biomarker-rich heavy components, whereas progressive shale diagenesis at later stages promoted the retention of highly mature, light hydrocarbons. In contrast, the lower sweet-spot interval represents a relatively closed system, where hydrocarbons generated during multiple stages continuously accumulated and were preserved as mixed charges; overprinting by multi-phase fluids progressively weakened sterane isomerization signals, rendering them unreliable indicators of individual charging events or final thermal maturity. This charging behavior provides a reasonable explanation for anomalously low or distorted biomarker parameters observed in intervals of low or similar maturity. Overall, the proposed charging model reconciles the observed reversal in crude-oil properties and, by shifting the interpretive focus from static maturity assessment to charging dynamics, offers a new theoretical basis for understanding lacustrine shale oil accumulation processes, and guiding sweet-spot selection and exploration-development strategies.
HUANG et al. (Sun,) studied this question.