Crowdsourced geospatial platforms constitute complex socio-technical systems in which data quality and reliability emerge from collective user behavior rather than centralized control. This study proposes a system-oriented, unsupervised machine learning framework to assess the reliability of crowdsourced building data using only intrinsic indicators. The framework is demonstrated through a large-scale analysis of OpenStreetMap building polygons in Tehran. Six intrinsic indicators—reflecting contributor activity, temporal dynamics, semantic instability, and geometric evolution—were normalized using fuzzy membership functions and objectively weighted based on their discriminative influence within a K-means clustering process. Five reliability classes were identified, ranging from very low to very high reliability. The resulting classification exhibited strong internal validity (average silhouette coefficient = 0.58) and pronounced spatial coherence (Global Moran’s I = 0.85, p < 0.001). This approach eliminates dependence on authoritative reference datasets, enabling scalable, reproducible, and feature-level reliability assessment in open geospatial systems. The framework provides a transferable methodological foundation for trust-aware analysis and decision-making in participatory and data-intensive systems.
Hassan et al. (Tue,) studied this question.