Fixed-bed reactors are pivotal in chemical industries, where catalyst loading critically determines reactor performance and economy. This critical review delineates and analyzes a three-stage evolution of loading technology: from empirical manual methods, through scenario-adaptive innovations, to closed-loop intelligent systems. It aims to decode the underlying scientific principles, assess the performance enhancements and inherent limitations of each stage, and critically examine the architectural framework and constraints of intelligent loading systems. Industrial validation data, such as from a 2.4 Mt/a hydrocracker, demonstrate potential improvements (e.g., 20–22% catalyst life extension, 1.8% bed pressure-drop fluctuation). However, the progression presents complex trade-offs in terms of scalability, cost, and standardization. The future direction is discussed, pointing toward addressing challenges in multi-physics modeling, digital twin integration, and fundamental research gaps. This work provides a balanced framework for evaluating loading technology evolution, acknowledging its context-dependent applicability.
Xu et al. (Wed,) studied this question.