• 40% lower SOC stocks under maize agriculture relative to native prairie in US Midwest U.S. • Perennial bioenergy feedstocks of switchgrass and miscanthus partially restored SOC after 5 y. • Soil δ 13 C analyses revealed perennial crop inputs to SOC, but stock changes varied across sites. • Replacing maize with perennial bioenergy feedstocks can partially restore SOC stocks. Maize ( Zea mays L.) is the dominant bioenergy feedstock in the US Midwest but its cultivation since the early 1800s has incurred substantial losses in soil organic carbon (SOC). We quantified differences in SOC stocks under perennial bioenergy crops of Panicum virgatum L. (switchgrass) and Miscanthus x giganteus Greef et Deuter (miscanthus) planted on former maize and soybean fields relative to maize-based annual cropping and native prairie. Comparisons were made at seven locations across Illinois, USA, spanning a range of climate and soil types. Across sites, SOC stocks to 1-m depth on an equivalent soil mass basis were 146 Mg C ha −1 under prairie, 107 Mg C ha −1 under miscanthus, 97.9 Mg C ha −1 under switchgrass, and 87.7 Mg C ha −1 under maize. Higher SOC demonstrates the potential of perennial bioenergy crops to rebuild the SOC deficit accrued under nearly two centuries of maize-based annual cropping. SOC stock increased in the first 5 years under mature bioenergy crops at four out of seven sites. Carbon isotope (δ 13 C) analyses of surface depths confirmed short-term increases in SOC to be derived from miscanthus and switchgrass. Stocks of SOC could be increased over time under miscanthus or switchgrass cultivation even with annual harvesting, though our measured rates of SOC accumulation were lower than previous estimates for Illinois and varied by site.
Kantola et al. (Wed,) studied this question.