Abstract An experiment was conducted to evaluate 3 individual feed additives on nursery pig growth performance and livability compared to a negative control (NC). The test products included a phytogenic blend (PH), a postbiotic product (PB), and a product containing a combination of phytogenic and postbiotic components that differed from the PH and PB treatments (PP). In total, 2,304 weaned pigs (5.4 ± 0.08 kg initial body weight; BW) were allotted to 18 replicate pens per treatment (32 pigs per pen) in 2 barns. Pens were blocked by location within barn and randomly allotted to treatment. Dietary treatments were fed in the first two nursery phases (phase 1: day 0 to 9; phase 2: day 9 to 22) followed by a common diet fed until the end of study (day 42). The phytogenic was included in the diet at 0.04%, the other test products were included in diets at 0.1%, and all diets included carbadox, pharmacological levels of zinc, and several other health-supporting feed technologies. Pen weights were recorded at the beginning and end of each phase. Data were analyzed using the lme4 package of R 4.1.2, and the statistical model included the fixed effect of treatment and the random effects of block and barn. Mortality was analyzed as a generalized linear mixed model with binomial distribution and reported as a probability. Growth performance in phase 1 did not differ by treatment, and likewise, no differences were observed for phase 2 final BW, average daily gain, or average daily feed intake. Phase 2 gain:feed tended to differ by treatment, with the greatest gain:feed observed for the postbiotic treatment (PB). Phase 3 growth performance did not differ by treatment, nor did overall growth performance. Phase 1 and 2 mortality tended to differ (P 0.10) between treatments. The NC treatment group had 4.15% mortality overall, whereas the treatments containing postbiotics resulted in 2.38% (PB) and 2.86% (PP) mortality (P = 0.106). In conclusion, most growth performance parameters were not influenced by dietary treatment; however, the treatments containing postbiotics tended to reduce mortality in the first 3 weeks post-weaning (P = 0.075). Overall, the postbiotic (PB) and PP group resulted in similar overall growth performance and numerically lower mortality compared to the negative control.
McGhee et al. (Wed,) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: