Metallo-β-Lactamase Expression Confers an Advantage to Pseudomonas aeruginosa Isolates Compared with Other β-Lactam Resistance Mechanisms, Favoring the Prevalence of Metallo-β-Lactamase Producers in a Clinical Environment

The Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolate TS-832035 was responsible for an outbreak that occurred in an Italian hospital between 1999 and 2002. It exhibited a high-level resistance to carbapenems due to the contemporary presence of two independent mechanisms: the production of a carbapenemase, coded by a bla(VIM-1) determinant carried by the chromosomal class 1 integron In70.2 (containing also the aacA4, aphA15, and aadA1 genes in its cassette array), and the lack of the OprD porin. We compared TS-832035 with a strictly related isolate, TS-103, whose resistance to carbapenems was due to the lack of the OprD porin only, as it did not carry In70.2. We evaluated their growth kinetics, in both separate cultures and competition assays, under permissive conditions. These experiments highlighted a significant in vitro fitness cost associated with the integron. On the contrary, none of the resistance determinants other than the bla(VIM-1) seemed to confer a real selective advantage to its host. Comparison of these results with the in vivo behavior, showing that the In70.2-carrying isolates largely prevailed over the In70.2-lacking ones, besides the detection of similar integrons in other Italian clinical isolates, evidenced the need to investigate accurately the causes of their large distribution, as possible soft spots could exist in the ability of their hosts to adapt to the hospital settings.