Recent observations of the rotation of distant galaxies and the implication for dark matter

Context. Recent measurements of gas velocity in the outer parts of high redshift galaxies suggest that steeply falling rotation curves may be common or even universal in these galaxies, in contrast to the near universal flat, non-declining rotation curves in nearby galaxies. Aims. The aim was to investigate the implications of these postulated steeply falling rotation curves for the role of dark matter in galaxy formation. Methods. Using an established computer code, the collapse of dark matter and baryonic matter together, starting with a variety of initial conditions, was simulated for comparison with the observed rotation curves. A simulation of collapsing baryonic matter on its own without dark matter was also carried out. The masses of the protogalaxies were chosen to produce a stellar disc in the same mass range as the observed galaxies at roughly the same redshift. Results. As soon as a smooth stellar disc was formed in the baryonic matter, with properties similar to the observed high redshift galaxies, the computed rotation curves were without exception relatively flat to large radius in the gas disc. Only a simulation without a dark matter halo was able to reproduce the observed rotation curves. Conclusions. This implies that if the high redshift steeply falling rotation curves turn out to be common, then the standard scenario of galaxy formation by baryonic matter falling into the potential well of a massive dark matter halo must be wrong, unless there is pressure support via velocity dispersion significantly higher than has so far been observed or resulted from our simulations. It would also imply that for these galaxies the flat rotation curves at low redshift must be due to dark matter which has subsequently fallen into the galactic potential well, or there must be some other explanation for their contemporary flat rotation curves other than dark matter.