In view of the depletion of high-grade magnesite resources in China, this study presents a comparative analysis of two industrial fused magnesia products produced via a flotation–fusion route. A low-grade magnesite (DSQLM-3, MgO 41.48 wt.%) was upgraded by reverse flotation to a concentrate (FDSQLM-3, MgO 47.55 wt.%) with >97% SiO2 removal. Two fused magnesia samples (FM-1 from natural high-grade ore DSQLM-1; FFM-3 from concentrate FDSQLM-3) were produced under identical arc-furnace melting (2800 °C, 4 h), followed by natural cooling. Although FFM-3 showed higher MgO (97.61 vs. 97.25 wt.%), its bulk density was comparable to FM-1 (3.45 vs. 3.46 g/cm3). XRD/Rietveld refinement and SEM-EDS indicated that CMS dominated the Ca–silicate assemblage in FM-1, whereas β/γ-C2S was observed in FFM-3, coinciding with a higher CaO/SiO2 (C/S) ratio (2.85 vs. 0.68). Image analysis further showed higher grain boundary microcrack metrics in FFM-3. These observations are consistent with reports in the literature stating that the β → γ transformation of C2S during cooling involves ~12% volume expansion that can contribute to cracking; however, cooling history and composition were not independently controlled in this industrial comparison, so the relationships are interpreted as data-supported associations rather than isolated causality. The results suggest that beneficiation strategies may benefit from managing residual oxide balance (especially C/S ratio) in addition to reducing total impurities. Mechanical and thermomechanical properties were not measured and should be evaluated in future work.
Wang et al. (Fri,) studied this question.