Multicomponent crystalline and amorphous elastic shells exhibit heterogeneous surface patterns that provide distinctive functionalities in cellular environments. Such patterning typically arises from the competition between short-range attractive and long-range repulsive interactions in membranes. Here, we demonstrate that the intrinsic competition between electrostatic repulsion and elastic deformation is sufficient to drive spontaneous surface patterning in elastic shells, requiring no additional attractive interactions. Using numerical simulations, we demonstrate pattern formation in mechanically homogeneous membranes with heterogeneous surface charge composition across different topologies, including spheres, discs, and flat periodic membranes. We also examine patterns in crystalline and amorphous shells of coassembled charged and neutral components with different bending rigidities. At low charge fraction, discrete charged surface domains form. At intermediate charge fraction, the competition between electrostatics and elasticity leads to elongated domains (rods) of the charged component, which results in lamellar patterns at nearly equal fraction of the charged and neutral components. At high charge fraction, nanodomains of the neutral component form. Amorphous shells exhibit similar progressions but with disordered structures rather than ordered lamellar patterns. These pattern morphologies are observed in both the closed shells and flat membranes. As salt concentration increases, all patterns coarsen due to the screening of electrostatic interactions.
Agrawal et al. (Tue,) studied this question.