This article presents a critical–propositional examination of Joaquin Cuelho’s Dialogue Article for the Theory of Objectivity Community – Hypothetical Novel Element 137 “Responsible for the Creation and Expansion of the Universe” in confrontation with the Theory of Objectivity (TO). The study investigates whether the hypothesis of a primordial “Element 137,” described as responsible for cosmic creation and expansion, can be sustained under the modal, ontological, and cosmological discipline of TO. The paper argues that the hypothesis cannot be accepted in its literal form as an absolute physical first cause. Instead, its strongest philosophical value emerges through reinterpretation: Element 137 may be understood as an extremely primitive phenomenic structure, already situated within the emerged universe, rather than as something prior to Nothingness. In this reclassified form, it may be read as a possible correlate of primary plasma, geometric condensation, convergence zones, primitive aurea, radiative-information support, or early inductive structuring processes. The analysis is organized through confrontation with the Seven Absolute Truths of the Theory of Objectivity, the phenomenic table of TO, the Inductor Effects, the cosmogonic theorem of the Perfect Sphere, and the cosmological Eras of TO. The article also places the discussion in dialogue with foundational and recent TO bibliography, as well as with broader philosophical and scientific interlocutors such as Heisenberg, Einstein, Bohm, Prigogine, Penrose, Hawking, and contemporary cosmological observation. The central conclusion is that Element 137 can only be theoretically preserved under TO if it is displaced from the category of absolute cause to that of a primitive, compositional, relational, boundary-bearing, and informationally irradiant phenomenic element. Thus, the article contributes to the modal discipline of cosmological speculation by clarifying the distinction between ontological foundation and regional physical manifestation. Keywords: Theory of Objectivity; Element 137; modal ontology; cosmology; Perfect Sphere; phenomenic elements; Inductor Effects; primary plasma; transcendence; informational radiation; cosmological philosophy; Zenodo.
Cabannas et al. (Tue,) studied this question.