Differential Clinical Workloads Among Faculty at a Major Academic Health Center

OBJECTIVE: The authors analyzed patient care (1981-1995) and financial data (1991-1996) to determine if differential workloads existed at a major academic health center. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Academic health centers differ markedly from community-based medical centers, but they are required to compete with others who have a more circumscribed mission and a responsibility for providing less complex care. Changes in health care systems may lessen incentives to generate clinical revenue and may adversely affect educational and research programs. METHODS: Patient care data at the University of Michigan Health System were analyzed by discipline for level of activity from 1981 to 1995 and were compared to professional and institutional financial data from 1991 to 1995. RESULTS: Surgeons represented 11% of the total full-time physicians throughout the period of the study (94 of the 836 Medical Center physicians, 1995). They accounted for 33% of hospital admissions (11, 616 of 35, 101) and 16% of outpatient visits (92, 364 of 568, 738). Since 1981, surgeons experienced a 249% increase in total operative workload (6799-16, 909 procedures), representing a 30% increase in operations/surgeon (138-180 operations). Surgical efforts in 1995 accounted for 29% of the total professional fee revenue and 240 million of the 512-million University of Michigan Hospital revenue. CONCLUSIONS: Surgeons had a greater collective and individual responsibility than did nonsurgeons for clinical activity and the financial viability of the academic health centers studied. Many proposals for financing health care delivery systems have the potential to exacerbate this differential. Restructuring of academic health centers must address this fact, lest their academic mission and scholarly activity be compromised.