Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Simulations of scattering and polarization properties for randomly oriented polyhedral ice crystals are presented based on the geometric optics and the far-field diffraction approximation. Particle shapes range from various hexagonal symmetric particles to highly complex shaped deterministic and random fractals. All calculations are performed at a wavelength of 0.55 µm. Hexagonal symmetric particles show several narrow scattering peaks besides the well known 22° and 46° halos. Column-like ice crystals provide neutral points (NP) at larger scattering angles than plate-like ice crystals. The ranges of NPs for column-like and plate-like crystals are separated at a scattering angle of about 156°, which may allow a polarimetric distinction between these two crystal types. The effects of particle size are studied by applying observationally derived aspect-ratio parameterizations to the individual particle types. Differences in the asymmetry parameter versus size relations for column-like particle types are basically caused by different aspect-ratio parameterizations rather than by the different types of columns. Thus, solid hexagonal columns appear representative for all column-like ice crystals. The dependency on crystal type is much stronger for plate-like particles. Increasing distortion of the crystal shapes leads to a considerable smoothing of the scattering signature. Scattering by complex-shaped particles is discussed for deterministic and randomized triadic Koch-fractals. The scattering signature for disordered fractals converges with increasing distortion and may be regarded as characteristic for complex-shaped ice crystals.
Macke et al. (Tue,) studied this question.