This study investigates the shear damage mechanisms in reinforced concrete (RC) beams through non-linear numerical modeling. Using the Finite Element Method (FEM) in ABAQUS, a Concrete Damaged Plasticity (CDP) framework was validated against experimental results and subsequently utilized for a 36-model parametric investigation. The study isolated the influence of stirrup spacing, diameter, and yield strength to evaluate their roles in ultimate shear capacity. The results indicated that while increasing stirrup diameter yielded modest capacity enhancements of approximately 7%, the impact of increasing yield strength was negligible, as the failure modes were primarily governed by concrete web crushing before reinforcement yielding could occur. These physical limit states were compared against the linear Truss Analogy adopted by major design standards—including ACI 318-19, Eurocode 2, and TS 500—to quantify discrepancies in heavily reinforced sections. The findings reveal that, strictly within the investigated parameter space (a/d = 2.67, f’c = 28.5 MPa), current linear equations can significantly overestimate the physical capacity gains provided by reinforcement modifications. These observations are configuration-specific and highlight the need for cautious application of linear models in heavily reinforced scenarios. Furthermore, the study suggests that utilizing 3D beam elements for transverse reinforcement provides a more nuanced representation of shear transfer mechanisms, such as dowel action, compared to standard truss models.
ÇAĞLAR et al. (Fri,) studied this question.