Cross-sectional study compares functional fitness in older women, suggesting social activity benefits are similar to exercise training.
Background/Objective : Social engagement may help preserve functional fitness (FF) throughout aging, but comparative studies are scarce. We compared FF in older women classified as socially active (SAC) versus exercise-trained (EXE) and insufficiently active (SED). Methods : Participants in SAC engaged in social activities requiring physical effort 3+ days/week ( n = 52; 69 ± 1 years); EXE performed physical training 3+ days/week for at least 3 months ( n = 70; 68 ± 1 years); and SED comprised institutionalized women, sedentary for 7–8 hr/day ( n = 43; 78 ± 2 years). FF tests included handgrip, sit-to-stand, timed-up-and-go, habitual and maximum walking speed, static and dynamic balance. Results : SAC and EXE performed light-to-moderate physical activity +150 min/week, while SED spent 10–12 hr/day sitting or in bed. FF performance was 10%–50% lower in SED versus SAC and EXE ( p < .05). Sit-to-stand failure rates were 14% in SED, 5% in SAC, and 3% in EXE. Timed-up-and-go test and maximum walking speed indicative of “high disability risk” were more predominant ( p < .05) in SED (79% and 43%) versus SAC (42% and 4%), and EXE (21% and 0%). Only 5% of SED completed static balance versus 73% of SAC and 70% of EXE. Dynamic balance deficits were severe in 95% of SED versus 21% of SAC and 17% of EXE. Conclusion : Older women with high social involvement had FF comparable to those engaged in exercise training, and both outperformed insufficiently active counterparts. Implications : Social activities requiring a moderate level of physical effort seem to preserve the FF of older women, which should be considered within interventions to improve FF throughout aging.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Geraldes et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: