Analysis reveals 22 Ne distillation in white dwarfs impacts cooling delays, suggesting significant habitable zones.
After carbon and oxygen, 22 Ne is the most abundant element in white dwarf (WD) interiors. As C/O WDs crystallize, they are predicted to go through a distillation process in the central layers if they have a sufficiently high 22 Ne mass fraction of ≳2.5%. Observational evidence for distillation comes from an overdensity of WDs on the Q-branch in Gaia color–magnitude diagrams, which indicates that ∼6% of massive WDs are delayed in their cooling by as much as ∼10 Gyr. However, it is unclear how these stars end up with such a high concentration of 22 Ne and if a significant fraction of the more common average-mass WDs go through distillation. We argue that a significant metal-rich stellar population in the solar neighborhood should lead to distilled WDs, without requiring a binary merger. We use MESA along with the carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen abundances derived from high-resolution spectroscopy of stars included in the Hypatia catalog to predict the 22 Ne mass fraction in their descendant WDs. We find that 0.6%–2.5% of the WDs in the solar neighborhood have sufficient 22 Ne in their interiors to go through multi-Gyr cooling delays, which could significantly inflate their numbers in the observed samples. Hence, 22 Ne distillation and long-lived habitable zones around WDs should be relatively common in the solar neighborhood. We also use a Galactic model to predict the fraction of WDs that go through distillation as a function of Galactocentric distance. The fraction of distilled WDs is ∼2%–8% near the Galactic center and declines steadily toward the outer disk.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Barrientos et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: