Forces During the Film Drainage and Detachment of NMC and Spherical Graphite in Particle–Bubble Interactions Quantified by CP-AFM and Modeling to Understand the Salt Flotation of Battery Black Mass

The salt flotation of graphite in the presence of lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide (NMC) was assessed by performing colloidal probe atomic force microscopy (CP-AFM) on sessile gas bubbles and conducting batch flotation tests with model lithium-ion-battery black mass. The modeling of film drainage and detachment during particle–bubble interactions provides insight into the fundamental microprocesses during salt flotation, a special variant of froth flotation. The interfacial properties of particles and gas bubbles were tailored with salt solutions containing sodium chloride and sodium acetate buffer. Graphite particles can attach to gas bubbles under all tested conditions in the range pH 3 to pH 10. The attractive forces for spherical graphite are strongest at high salt concentrations and pH 3. The conditions for the attachment of NMC to gas bubbles were evaluated with simulations using the Stokes–Reynolds–Young–Laplace model for film drainage, under consideration of DLVO forces and a hydrodynamic slip to account for irregularities of the particle surface. CP-AFM measurements in the capillary force regime provide additional parameters for the modeling of salt flotation, such as the force and work of detachment. The contact angles of graphite and NMC particles during retraction and detachment from gas bubbles were obtained from a quasi-equilibrium model using CP-AFM data as input. All CP-AFM experiments and theoretical results suggest that pristine NMC particles do not attach to gas bubbles during flotation, which is confirmed by the low rate of NMC recovery in batch flotation tests.