This analysis reveals the validity of the Ramanujan sum in quantum electrodynamics and condensed matter, suggesting important implications.
It is a popular paradoxical exercise to show that the infinite sum of positive integer numbers is equal to –1/12, sometimes called the Ramanujan sum. This result is actually well-defined in a proper mathematical sense. Here we propose a qualitative approach, much like that of a physicist, to show how the value –1/12 can make sense and, in fact, appears in certain physical quantities where this type of summation is involved. At the light of two physical examples, taken respectively from condensed matter – the Landau diamagnetism – and quantum electrodynamics – the Casimir effect – that illustrate this strange sum, we present a systematic way to extract this Ramanujan term from the infinity. In both examples, the “infinite” appears to be a vacuum energy and the Ramanujan sum is revealed by a response function to an external parameter.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gilles Montambaux (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched one closely related paper. Consider it for comparative context: