Assessing geology curriculum reveals students grasp sedimentary basins better than geophysics, suggesting a need for improved resources.
We need to educate students and the public about addressing natural resource challenges to maintain civilization moving into a sustainable future. Because US mineral and energy resources are found in its continental crust and sedimentary basins, introductory geology students need to be well-informed about US crust and basins. We think that creating effective videos about these topics is the best way to engage students to want to learn more. In preparation for making these videos, we researched what introductory geology students are taught and what they learn about these topics. Student interviews informed us about learned curriculum, and taught curriculum was analyzed using a novel keyword-counting method applied to textbook indices. We found that geophysics is stressed twice as much as geology, radiometric dating, and sedimentary basins. We expected that students would have learned more about geophysics and less about the other topics; however, this was not the case. Students knew more about geology, and less about geophysics, radiometric dating, and sedimentary basins. To make effective videos on these topics, we need to explain the following threshold concepts: seismic refraction to scaffold student understanding of crustal geophysics, as well as radiometric dating and deep time to understand crustal geology and the economic importance of sedimentary basins.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Crowley et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: