Performance Comparison of Hybrid and Standalone Piezoelectric Energy Harvesters Under Vortex-Induced Vibrations

This study investigates the effect of incorporating an electromagnetic harvester inside the bluff body of a 2-DoF hybrid harvester in comparison to a standalone piezoelectric harvester for various external loads. The harvester is excited through a vortex-induced vibration owing to the resultant wake vortices created behind the bluff body. The coupled dynamics of the two harvester components are modeled, and numerical simulations are conducted to evaluate the system’s performance under varying electrical loads. Numerical results show that at high, optimum electrical load, the standalone piezoelectric harvester outperforms the hybrid harvester. Nevertheless, for small electrical loads, the results show that the hybrid harvester outperforms the standalone PZT harvester by up to 18% in peak power output, while reducing the bandwidth by approximately 10% compared to the standalone piezoelectric harvester. Optimal spring stiffness values were identified, with the hybrid harvester achieving its maximum output power at a spring stiffness of 83.56 N/m. These findings underscore the need for careful design considerations, as the hybrid harvester may not achieve enhanced power output and bandwidth under higher electrical loads.