Observational advances have allowed the detection of galaxies, protoclusters, and galaxy clusters at higher and higher redshifts, opening a new view into extreme galaxy evolution. I present an argument that the high redshift, massive galaxies discovered over the last decade are really the most massive galaxies within protocluster-cores of galaxy clusters at z~2, and that they are the partial descendants of same galaxies discovered by JWST at z~9. To that end, I present The Manhattan Suite, a set of $100$ high resolution zoom-in simulations of the most massive galaxy clusters, out to 9\,Rᵥir, selected at $z = 2$ from a (1.5\,cGpc)³ parent volume, and simulated using the Simba model. Unlike other cluster suites, my selection at $z = 2$ ensures that these systems are biased in a similar fashion to observations, in that they should be the brightest and the most massive by construction at z 2. I show that my sample is able to reproduce extremely star-bursting protoclusters such as SPT2349-56, high redshift galaxy clusters XLSSC122 and JKCS0249, and the wealth of massive (sometimes quenched) galaxies at z 3 and up to z ~ 9. I argue that these systems are intimately linked, and represent the same evolutionary history.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Douglas Rennehan (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: