Chilling Out or Heating Up: Investigating the Thermal Perception in Resting Areas of Small Urban Parks

Small urban parks are the dominant form of green spaces in most Japanese cities and hold great potential for heat stress mitigation. However, most research has focused on large urban parks, leaving a knowledge gap in how small parks can be designed to mitigate heat. Given that small parks are primarily used for rest, we focused on resting areas and assessed their thermal conditions in three typical small parks in Kyoto, Japan. We then examined how the spatial arrangements of park elements influenced thermal conditions. Results revealed that nearly half of the resting areas were uncomfortable, underscoring the urgent need for spatial design improvements. Linear mixed-effects models showed that while shade elements, such as tree canopies and roofs, most effectively enhanced thermal perception, their effectiveness was distance- and orientation-dependent. We also found a critical mismatch between green ground and shade elements that adversely affected thermal conditions. Our findings highlight that strategic spatial design, particularly the thoughtful placement of shade elements and resting areas, is the key to providing thermal comfort in small urban parks. This study provides evidence that small parks can act as urban heat spots if poorly designed, but with appropriate design they can become cool refuges.