Cool roof and green roof have been acknowledged as effective heat mitigation strategies for fighting against the urban heat island (UHI). However, empirical data in hot–humid climate are still insufficient. Experimental conventional, cool and green roofs (three types) were established to comprehensively investigate the thermal performances in Hong Kong under typical summer conditions, as retrofitting strategies for an office building. The holistic vertical thermal behavior was investigated. The comparative cooling potentials were assessed. The results reveal a “vertical thermal sequence” in peak temperatures of each substrate layer for the conventional, cool and green roofs on a sunny day. However, local reversion in the thermal sequence may occur on a rainy day. Green roof-plot C (GRC) demonstrates the highest thermal damping effect, followed by plot B (GRB), A (GRA) and the cool roof (CR) in summer. On a sunny day, the thermal dampening effectiveness of the substrates in the three green roofs is consistent: drainage > soil > water reservoir > root barrier. The holistic vertical thermal profiling was constructed in a high-rise office context in Hong Kong. The diurnal temperature profiles indicate all roof systems could effectively attenuate the temperature fluctuations. The daily maximum surface temperature reduction (SDMR) was introduced for cooling potential characterization of the cool roof and green roofs with multiple vegetation types. On a sunny day, the cool roof and green roofs all showed significant cooling potential. SDMR on the concrete tile of the best performing system was GRC (26 °C), followed by GRB (22. 4 °C), GRA (20. 7 °C) and CR (13. 3 °C), respectively. The SDMR on the ceiling ranked as GRC, GRB, GRA and CR, with 2. 9 °C, 2. 4 °C, 2. 1 °C and 2. 1 °C, separately. On a rainy day, the cooling effect was still present but greatly diminished. A critical insight of a “warming effect at the ceiling” of the green roof was revealed. This research offers critical insights for unlocking rooftop cooling potential, endorsing cool roof and green roof as pivotal solutions for sustainable urban environments.
Zhao et al. (2026) studied this question.