This assessment evaluates the uncertainty of SuperDove remote sensing reflectance in aquatic environments, suggesting implications for monitoring applications.
The use of high-resolution data in aquatic applications increased significantly in the last decade with the launch of decametre-scale optical sensors. More recently, commercial very-high resolution (VHR) sensors, offering finer spatial and temporal resolutions, have shown the potential of complementing data from high-resolution missions. Planet SuperDove (SD), with a band-setting similar to the Copernicus Sentinel-2 MultiSpectral Instrument (S2-MSI), a 3-m spatial resolution and quasi-daily revisiting time, show the potential for widening water monitoring applications to smaller water basins, and finer-scale phenomena. However, the uncertainties in SD products need to be quantified, to assess their fitness-for-purpose for these applications. This work aims to provide uncertainty estimates for SD-derived aquatic remote sensing reflectance (R RS ) in different water types, benefitting from the radiometric measurements of the AERONET-OC network. R RS was derived from both Surface Reflectance (SR) products, distributed by Planet, or from data processed with ACOLITE. The comparability between SD and S2-MSI products was also assessed comparing R RS and Rayleigh-corrected reflectance (R RC ) from S2-MSI and SD. The results indicate generally low performance across all bands for both SD R RS products, except in the most turbid waters, and highlight the lack of a publicly available robust atmospheric correction processor for SD data for most optical water types. The comparison to S2-MSI shows promising results only when comparing R RC values, but differences still suggest issues associated with calibration and radiometry of the SD sensors. The results also highlight the need for a harmonization strategy to ensure consistent integration of these datasets within multi-source monitoring systems.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cazzaniga et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: