Reduced soil moisture (SM) together with elevated vapor pressure deficit (VPD) suppresses gross primary productivity (GPP) and thus weakens the capacity of the terrestrial carbon pool. Against the backdrop of global climate change, soil and atmospheric drought exert a more profound impact on vegetation growth, and their combined impacts remain unclear. Based on multi-source remote sensing observations and reanalysis datasets, three vegetation remote sensing indices, GPP, SIF, and NDVI (collectively referred to as Vegetation Remote Sensing Indices, VSI), are employed in this study to assess the relative impacts of soil and atmospheric drought on terrestrial vegetation. First, Copula-based conditional probabilities are applied to identify which factor (reduced SM or high VPD) plays a dominant role under conditions of declining vegetation productivity and to determine their corresponding thresholds. Furthermore, the underlying driving mechanisms are elucidated by utilizing Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) for path analysis to clarify how climatic factors indirectly affect vegetation productivity by influencing SM and VPD. The results suggest that vegetation growth in China’s different climatic zones is affected by distinct factors. Specifically, SM is the primary factor influencing vegetation productivity, dominating 71.16% of the nation’s vegetated areas. Its influence is particularly pronounced in arid and semi-arid regions. In contrast, the impact of VPD is predominantly concentrated in semi-humid plain regions. Furthermore, the critical thresholds for SM in different climate zones are identified: the threshold averages approximately 0.33 m3/m3 in humid and plateau regions and 0.13 m3/m3 in arid and semi-arid regions. The SEM analysis further reveals the complex pathways by which climatic variables influence vegetation growth. In SM-dominated regions, higher SM directly promotes vegetation growth; in VPD-dominated regions, drier air imposes a stronger suppression on vegetation growth. Nonetheless, the plateau temperate semi-arid zone demonstrates distinct hydrometeorological characteristics. Attributed to the region’s unique hydrometeorological conditions, the negative effects of higher VPD are generally outweighed by the favorable conditions for photosynthesis with which it co-occurs. These findings clarify the intricate impacts of SM and VPD on vegetation productivity, providing a foundational framework for the development of tailored ecological management strategies and drought early warning systems.
Zhou et al. (2026) studied this question.