To clarify the differences in and mechanisms of soil detachment before and after soil collapse, five typical granite soil layers (red soil, red soil–sandy soil, sandy soil, sandy soil–debris, and debris layers) of Benggang in Anxi County, Fujian Province, were studied via laboratory runoff scouring tests, and the detachment capabilities and influencing factors of undisturbed (original) and disturbed (colluvial deposit) soils were compared. The results showed that disturbance due to soil collapse significantly increases the soil detachment capacity by an average of 1046 times, with the greatest increase occurring in the red soil–sand soil layer (3494 times) and the smallest increase occurring in the debris layer (63 times). The undisturbed soil detachment capacity increases with increasing soil depth, whereas the disturbed soil capacity first increases but then decreases, with the sand layer having the highest capacity. Hydrodynamic fitting results revealed that undisturbed red soil has a linear relationship, red soil–sandy soil and sandy soil layers have power function relationships, and sandy soil–debris and debris layers have logarithmic relationships with flow shear stress. Disturbed red soil and red soil–sandy soil layers are linearly related, whereas the other layers are logarithmically related. Correlation analysis revealed that undisturbed soil detachment is significantly negatively correlated with clay, silt, gravel, free iron oxide, and free alumina contents and positively correlated with sand content. Disturbed soil shows similar correlations, but it has a negative correlation with organic matter instead of gravel. Structural equation modelling (SEM) path analysis revealed that undisturbed soil detachment is affected mainly by negative free alumina oxide content (path coefficient of −0.87) and flow shear stress (path coefficient of 0.14), whereas disturbed soil is controlled mainly by negative shear strength (path coefficient of −0.76) and positive flow shear stress (path coefficient of 0.49). This study elucidates the mechanism by which colluvial deposit disturbance accelerates soil detachment, providing a theoretical basis for the prevention and control of Benggang erosion in the hilly regions of southern China with red soil. Moreover, the comparative research strategy adopted in this study offers a reference for related investigations in similar erosion-prone areas.
Li et al. (Fri,) studied this question.