Singe-crystal (SC) nickel-rich layered oxide cathodes, composed of boundary-free particles with high tap density, offer significant advantages in volumetric energy density and mechanical strength compared with polycrystalline (PC) cathode materials. However, as the nickel content increases (≥80%), SC Ni-rich cathodes often suffer from faster performance degradation than PC cathodes of the same composition, and the underlying causes of this discrepancy remain poorly understood. Herein, we reveal the distinct Ni redox behaviors that govern the electrochemical performance of SC and PC Ni-rich cathodes using multiscale and operando characterization techniques. Our results indicate that the increasingly heterogeneous Ni oxidation process in SC cathodes leads to the additional irreversible oxygen redox activity that deteriorates both the mechanical and chemical structures. In contrast, PC cathodes, despite with more pronounced surface reconstruction, exhibit greater chemomechanical stability due to homogeneous redox reactions during charging. Consequently, we find that bulk degradation, more than surface reactions, ultimately leads to fast capacity decay of SC Ni-rich cathodes during cycling. This work offers a comprehensive view on the impact of Ni redox evolutions on the chemomechanical stability in Ni-rich layered oxide cathodes, providing new insights into the longstanding performance gap between SC and PC cathodes, and guiding the rational design of Ni-rich cathode architectures.
Wang et al. (2026) studied this question.