With inherent negative stiffness and nonlinearity, reluctance magnetic levitation systems struggle to sustain satisfactory control performance across a long stroke. To address this issue, theoretical analysis, control strategy design, and experiments are performed. First, the magnetic and dynamic behavior are analyzed, and the corresponding mathematical model is derived. Then, the control system analysis is conducted, and the feedback properties are described from a physically intuitive perspective. Moreover, with a standard PD/PID compensator, a clear trade-off emerges between robustness at small air gaps and tracking performance at large air gaps. Subsequently, a control strategy combining feedforward compensation with gain scheduling PD is designed. It is directly mapped from the reluctance actuator parameters without relying on engineering experience and can be flexibly configured to meet performance requirements. Finally, time-domain and frequency-domain experiments are conducted. The positioning control results show that the proposed strategy effectively shortens the settling time of long-stroke step responses and improves the uniformity of the dynamic performance. The frequency response evidence shows a more uniform response over the full stroke and simultaneous improvements in robustness and tracking, effectively resolving the long-stroke conflict.
Pei et al. (Wed,) studied this question.