Manuscript revision r4. RSOS-260797 planar carrier-set theorem; this revision succeeds r2 (the ScholarOne submission currently under RSOS initial assessment) and incorporates external structural review findings plus tonight's verification work. Changelog r2 → r3 → r4: r2 → r3 (intermediate revision; not separately deposited on Zenodo): Bibliography additions: Dawood (2019), Skowron abstract now describes the planar theorem only. §8.4 reproducibility discussion expanded; engagement with Boldo et al. (2023) floating-point certification framework added. r3 → r4 (post-Manusights-corrected-review revision; this deposit): Seven essential revisions and five recommended revisions from the Manusights structural review incorporated. Thirteen additional references added: Atanassov, Boldo et al. (2023), Bustince, Dawood, de Figueiredo richer methods that retain auxiliary state are outside this class rather than incorrect." Backup-venue list catalogued (Reliable Computing, J. Symbolic Computation, J. Logic and Algebraic Methods in Programming, Numerical Algorithms, Soft Computing). Page count: ~35 pp. Tonight's (2026-04-26 / 2026-04-27) line-by-line verification work on the broader Memoirs monograph (10.5281/zenodo.19822813) verified the base rigidity proof (Stage 1/2/3 of the three-stage characterisation), the four-cell classification across the Cayley-Dickson tower (Cell 1 ℂ, Cell 2 ℍ, Cell 3 provably empty by Hurwitz, Cell 4 𝕆), Definition 4.3 (native O(1) two-way criterion), and the universality theorem. Several specification tightenings identified by that verification work apply to the RSOS planar theorem as well; they are scheduled for a future r5 revision and are not yet incorporated in r4 deposited here. Status: r4 is the rapid-hardening revision prepared after the Manusights structural review surfaced four legitimate findings on the originally-deposited r2 (ScholarOne r2 currently under RSOS initial assessment by Editor Brandrick). Restricted-access priority deposit; access requests evaluated case-by-case.
Eric D. Martin (Mon,) studied this question.